How beneficial it is to group students according to their level of ability?
|
While homogeneous and heterogeneous classrooms are all common approaches, there is also a third placement method, and it is called ability grouping. The latter doesn’t consider the age or the grade a particular student is attending but rather their proficiency in a specific class.
Show Thus, you may have students that are 2nd and 6th grade attending the same classroom, which is quite common for individually gifted kids or those that have certain learning disabilities. Keep in mind that in most cases, these groups consist of up to 10 students and have a customized curriculum. Who Determines Ability Groups? In most cases, an educator’s job is to evaluate the grades, proficiency, and acquired knowledge of a particular student before placing them in an ability group. The pen and pencil tests are the most effective way to determine whether someone belongs to a higher or a lower classroom. Keep in mind that a student who later excels in a specific class can be moved to a higher ability group and vice versa. Thus, if the educator determines that their initial evaluation wasn’t as precise, they can move children who require more education in a particular matter to lower groups. How Does Ability Grouping Work? Given that the students are grouped by their proficiency and knowledge, the instruction pace is usually the one that all of the students are comfortable with. As the class progresses, the educator may decide to spend more or less time on specific assignments, allowing them to show particular interest or ask a question about a designated matter. The Positives Of Ability Grouping One of the coolest points about ability grouping is that educators have an easier time presenting the curriculum and targeting instruction according to the level of students in the group. Additionally, the fact that most of the students are of the same proficiency will allow them to have more confidence when it comes to entering discussions and openly stating opinions on some issues. This is something that a lot of children have a problem within regular classrooms for the fear that they will either be mocked (for being “wrong”) or marked as “nerds.” The Negatives Of Ability Grouping The main issue is that once a student is placed in an ability group, they may not get back to the regular track. This means that someone who had temporary learning disabilities cannot join their peers as they spent too much time away from the traditional classroom instructions. Concluding Thoughts Much like with homogeneous and heterogeneous placement, ability grouping is something that should be well thought out. Yes, it does carry a set of potential advantages for the designated students, but it shouldn’t undermine one’s need for a more individualized approach. Ability grouping first appeared in American education in the 1920s when the use of mental testing was a valued indicator of potential student performance. At the elementary level, ability grouping is the practice of dividing students into groups or classes based on school aptitude. Grouping may occur based on test scores or school records of grades. Issues with ability grouping include its impact on self-esteem, effectiveness of instruction and equity among minority groups. Basics of Ability GroupingAbility grouping in elementary schools occurs in several different ways. Dividing students into high, middle and low groups involves a separation of students into different classrooms for an entire school day or for single-subject instruction. Separation for single-subject instruction also occurs in cross-grade grouping, where students may find themselves in classrooms with students of different grade levels but similar abilities in a subject. Teachers group students within the classroom to provide students with small work groups for learning in a specific subject. In this formation, students remain in a single classroom with students of mixed abilities and may be grouped with a variety of students throughout the course of the day. Finally, enriched or accelerated classes offer grouping for students who have high achievement or aptitude. ProsAccording to the National Education Association, supporters of ability grouping cite the ability of teachers to adjust the pace of instruction for student needs as a strength of ability grouping. Another positive aspect of grouped students is the ability to tailor instructional content for the level of the group. Additionally, an ERIC Digest report by Carol Nelson states that ability grouping for a particular educational purpose benefits students. Nelson's report found that students who were grouped in cooperative learning groups -- with heterogeneous ability rather than homogeneous ability -- developed skills in critical thinking competencies, positive social interactions, collaboration abilities and the ability to understand other perspectives. ConsDetractors of ability grouping state that the lower learning groups are disproportionately filled with poor and minority students, according to the NEA Research Spotlight on Academic Ability Grouping. Opponents also claim that students in these lower groups receive lower quality instruction, which contributes to the achievement gap. Author Anne Wheelock's research on ability grouping found that placement into ability groups is often based on a subjective view of intelligence. Wheelock's work also found that ability grouping led to students self-labeling their own ability and increased or decreased expectations of the teacher based on group labels. Finally, once students enter an ability group, they are likely to remain in that ability group for the duration of their academic career. Other ConsiderationsThe characteristics of the grouping program and the manner in which it is enacted affect the overall success or failure of ability grouping. Four elements of grouping strategies can affect the overall success of the strategy. The means by which teachers modify the curriculum for each group contributes to the academic achievement of the students. Maintaining flexibility in grouping, or the ability to move students based on achievement, contributes to continued growth in students. Using multiple means of assessment prior to placement can contribute to the overall effectiveness of grouping, and single-subject grouping that allows students to be placed at high, middle or low in different subjects affects outcome of grouping. References
Resources
Writer Bio Based in Los Angeles, Jana Sosnowski holds Master of Science in educational psychology and instructional technology, She has spent the past 11 years in education, primarily in the secondary classroom teaching English and journalism. Sosnowski has also worked as a curriculum writer for a math remediation program. She earned a Bachelor of Arts in print journalism from the University of Southern California. What are the benefits of ability grouping?Ability grouping increases student achievement by allowing teachers to focus instruction, proponents say. Teaching a group of like-ability students allows teachers to adjust the pace of instruction to students' needs.
Is grouping students by ability level an effective way for students to learn?Positive Aspects of Ability Grouping
Students and educators can benefit from ability grouping. Some of the potential positive effects of ability grouping include: Students in smaller groups may receive more individual attention than they would in a large classroom setting.
Which of the following is an advantage of in class ability grouping?Advantages. A faster learning pace: Exceptional students may get bored occasionally or even take action after finishing their work or understanding a concept much faster than peers. However, in groups or classrooms that practice ability grouping, they can move faster along with their peers of the same capacity level.
Why is it important to group students in learning?Group activities enable students to discover deeper meaning in the content and improve thinking skills. The most effective use of group work is that which engages students with higher-level content that is thought-provoking, difficult to understand, or has multiple interpretations.
|
