Which of the Big 5 personality dimensions is the best predictor?
|
The differences between people’s personalities can be broken down in terms of five major traits—often called the “Big Five.” Each one reflects a key part of how a person thinks, feels, and behaves. The Big Five traits are: Show
Individual personalities are thought to feature each of these five broad traits to some degree. When the traits are measured, some people rate higher and others rate lower: Someone can be more conscientious and less agreeable than most people, for instance, while scoring about average on the other traits. These traits remain fairly stable during adulthood. People can also differ on the more specific facets that make up each of the Big Five traits. A relatively extroverted person might be highly sociable but not especially assertive. The five-factor model is widely used by personality researchers, but it is not the only model. A more recently introduced six-factor model known as HEXACO adds the factor of honesty-humility to the original five traits. ContentsHow the Big Five Personality Traits Are Measured
The Big Five traits are typically assessed using one of multiple questionnaires. While these tests vary in the exact terms they use for each trait, they essentially cover the same broad dimensions, providing high-to-low scores on each: openness to experience (also called open-mindedness or just openness), conscientiousness, extroversion (the reverse of which is introversion), agreeableness, and neuroticism (sometimes negative emotionality or emotional stability). One test, the latest version of the Big Five Inventory, asks how much a person agrees or disagrees that he or she is someone who exemplifies various specific statements, such as:
Based on a person’s ratings for dozens of these statements (or fewer, for other tests), an average score can be calculated for each of the five traits. What does your score on the Big Five tell you?Created with Sketch. Scores on a Big Five questionnaire provide a sense of how low or high a person rates on a continuum for each trait. Comparing those scores to a large sample of test takers—as some online tests do—offers a picture of how open, conscientious, extroverted (or introverted), agreeable, and neurotic one is relative to others. How were the Big Five traits determined?Created with Sketch. Analyzing English words used to describe personality traits, researchers used statistical techniques to identify clusters of related characteristics. This led to a small number of overarching trait dimensions that personality psychologists have scientifically tested in large population samples. Who developed the Big Five personality traits?Created with Sketch. The Big Five were not determined by any one person—they have roots in the work of various researchers going back to the 1930s. In 1961, Ernest Tupes and Raymond Christal identified five personality factors that others would reanalyze and rename. Lewis Goldberg used the term Big Five in 1981 to describe these broad factors. Do Big Five tests measure more specific traits?Created with Sketch. Some Big Five questionnaires break the five main traits down into smaller sub-components or “facets,” which are correlated with each other but can be independently measured. In the Big Five Inventory, for instance, “sociability” and “assertiveness” are distinct facets of extroversion, while “organization” and “responsibility” are facets of conscientiousness. article continues after advertisement Why the Big Five Personality Traits Are Important
The five-factor model not only helps people better understand how they compare to others and to put names to their characteristics. It’s also used to explore relationships between personality and many other life indicators. These include consequential outcomes such as physical health and well-being as well as success in social, academic, and professional contexts. Personality psychologists have observed reliable associations between how people rate on trait scales and how they fare or feel, on average, in various aspects of their lives. What can Big Five scores tell us about other outcomes?Created with Sketch. Quite a lot, at least in Western samples. There is reliable evidence, for example, that extroversion is associated with subjective well-being, neuroticism with lower work commitment, and agreeableness with religiousness. Certain traits have been linked to mortality risk. However, these are overall patterns and don’t mean that a trait necessarily causes any of these outcomes. Can Big Five personality traits change?Created with Sketch. Yes. While personality trait measures tend to be fairly consistent over short periods of time in adulthood, they do change over the course of a lifetime. There’s also reason to believe that deliberate personality change is possible. The Big Five and Other Personality Tests
Various ways of representing major traits have been proposed, and personality researchers continue to disagree on the number of distinct characteristics that can be measured. The five-factor model dominates the rest, as far as psychologists are concerned, although multiple types of assessments exist to measure the five traits. Outside of academic psychology, tests that aim to sort people into personality types—including the Myers-Briggs/MBTI and Enneagram—are highly popular, though many experts take issue with such tests on scientific grounds. The five-factor model has conceptual and empirical strengths that others lack. How do Big Five tests compare to the Myers-Briggs?Created with Sketch. For a number of reasons, many personality psychologists consider Big Five tests superior to the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator. These include concerns about the reliability of the types assigned by the Myers-Briggs and the validity of the test—though there is some overlap between its dimensions (which include extroversion-introversion) and the Big Five. Do the Big Five capture personality types?Created with Sketch. It depends on how strictly you define a “type.” Research indicates that for any given trait, people fall at various points along a continuum rather than fitting neatly into categories. While some identify wholeheartedly as a total extrovert or introvert, for example, there are many shades in between, and most of us would score somewhere in the middle. Do Big Five tests have known limitations?Created with Sketch. Yes. Some have criticized the five-factor model for its origins in data rather than in theory and argued that it does not encompass all fundamental traits (see HEXACO). There is also evidence that current tests provide less reliable results outside of Western, industrialized countries. Essential Reads
Science Supports the Usefulness of Knowing How to Respond to Expectations Contrary to claims that the Four Tendencies are unscientific, there is scientific support for the four personality types and why knowing your type is useful.  Personality Assessments: Separating Science From Nonsense The question of whether it is relevant to assess personality in hiring is the wrong one to ask. Instead, ask yourself about the best way for measuring personality.
Do Major Relationship Events Change Your Personality? We experience many relationship events over time, such as marrying or getting divorced. But how is our personality related to these events? Do You Have a Burnout-Prone Personality? Burnout is an endless maze of anxiety, self-hatred, and contempt for yourself, coworkers, and employers. Your personality may be the link to change. Recent Posts
Does Everyone Really Have a "Type"?Theresa E. DiDonato Ph.D. on November 18, 2022 in Meet, Catch, and Keep Popular culture encourages the idea of a romantic "type." Recent research isolates and evaluates potential personality similarities between ex-partners and current partners. Popular culture encourages the idea of a romantic "type." Recent research isolates and evaluates potential personality similarities between ex-partners and current partners.
Can Fathers Be Maternal?Christine B. L. Adams M.D. on November 15, 2022 in Living on Automatic Can fathers nurture children as well as or better than mothers? How much does a parent's gender determine good or poor parenting? Can fathers nurture children as well as or better than mothers? How much does a parent's gender determine good or poor parenting?
4 Personality Traits of the Best Romantic PartnersSeth J. Gillihan PhD on November 15, 2022 in Think, Act, Be Four traits consistently predict which couples are most satisfied with their relationship. Four traits consistently predict which couples are most satisfied with their relationship.
8 Benefits of Being a Nice PersonSusan Krauss Whitbourne Ph.D. on November 8, 2022 in Fulfillment at Any Age You may wonder sometimes whether it’s worth trying to be a bit nicer to the people you know. A new comprehensive review of nearly 4,000 studies shows eight ways the effort can pay off. You may wonder sometimes whether it’s worth trying to be a bit nicer to the people you know. A new comprehensive review of nearly 4,000 studies shows eight ways the effort can pay off.
Can Personality Affect Our Ability to Detect Infidelity?Madeleine A. Fugère Ph.D. on November 8, 2022 in Dating and Mating Certain personality facets are associated with an increased or decreased tendency to detect a partner's infidelity. Certain personality facets are associated with an increased or decreased tendency to detect a partner's infidelity.
What Do You Really Want in a Dating Partner?Gary W. Lewandowski Jr. Ph.D. on November 8, 2022 in The Psychology of Relationships What are you looking for in a relationship partner? Ironically, what you think you want often does not match up with the partners you actually prefer. What are you looking for in a relationship partner? Ironically, what you think you want often does not match up with the partners you actually prefer.
If You're Feeling More Neurotic Than Usual Right Now, That's NormalSuzanne Degges-White Ph.D. on November 7, 2022 in Lifetime Connections You're not the same person you were a few years ago, and it might take some concerted effort to get back on track with stress levels, social skills, and meeting obligations. You're not the same person you were a few years ago, and it might take some concerted effort to get back on track with stress levels, social skills, and meeting obligations.
Like Man, Like Dog: Owner-Dog ResemblanceJuliane Bräuer Ph.D. on November 7, 2022 in Smarter Than You Think Is it really true that dogs and owners are similar? Is it really true that dogs and owners are similar?
Who Dated (and Who Didn’t) During COVIDBrian Collisson Ph.D. on October 11, 2022 in Dating Toxic or Tender Did certain personality traits and attachment styles make people more or less likely to form new romantic relationships during COVID? Which Big 5 trait is the strongest predictor of relationship satisfaction?The trait with the most consistent evidence of partner effects is Emotional Stability. Having a partner low in Emotional Stability is associated with higher levels of relationship dissatisfaction (e.g.; Barelds, 2005; Botwin et al., 1997), and even a greater risk of marital dissolution (Kurdek, 1993).
Which of the following Big 5 personality factors is the strongest predictor of effective leadership?Extroversion was the strongest predictor of leadership emergence — who becomes a leader — and leadership effectiveness — who's successful in a leadership position.
What is the most reliable Big 5 personality test?The Big Five Personality Test is by far the most scientifically validated and reliable psychological model to measure personality. This test is, together with the Jung test (MBTI test style) and the DISC assessment, one of the most well known personality tests worldwide. This free personality test is fast and reliable.
What is the most important Big 5 personality trait?According to Essentials of Organizational Behavior: 14th Edition, the big five personality dimension that has the biggest influence on job performance is conscientiousness. Those who score higher in this trait are likely to have higher levels of job-related knowledge as those who are highly conscientious learn more.
|
