Neutrogena vs La Roche posay sunscreen Reddit

I came across this website when I was looking to buy a new sunscreen since the Neutrogena Clear Face SPF 55 one kept burning my eyes. Turns out the Neutrogena one is one of the worst ones you can buy based on UVA protection and health concerns, and the new one I just bought (Babyganics) has low toxicity but only moderate UVA protection. After learning this, I figured I'd post about my experience here to hopefully help other people struggling to find a good sunscreen.

About the website: The website rates sunscreens on a score from 1-10, with 1 being the best and 10 being the worst. 2/3 of the score is based on UVA protection, and the remaining 1/3 is based on health concerns. If the product has other things like comes in a spray form, contains oxybenzone, or has misleading SPF, then its score is further reduced.

Other popular sunscreens from the ScA recommendation list (alphabetized): (Use Command+F to find yours)

  • Alba Botanica Facial Sunscreen, Fragrance Free, SPF 30

    • Score: 3/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Alba Botanica Sport Mineral Sunscreen, Fragrance Free, SPF 45

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Good UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Aveeno Baby Continuous Protection Sensitive Skin Lotion Sunscreen, SPF 50

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • Aveeno Active Naturals Natural Protection Lotion Sunscreen, SPF 50

    • Score: 3/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

    • Same for baby version

  • Banana Boat Sport Performance Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 50+

    • Score: 7/10 (Poor)

    • SPF may be lower than advertised

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

  • Blue Lizard Australian Sunscreen, Face, SPF 30+

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

  • CeraVe Sunscreen Face Lotion, SPF 50*

    • Score: 7/10 (Poor)

    • SPF value may be less than advertised

    • Contains retinyl palmitate, which may damage sun-exposed skin (READ about the risk of VITAMIN A + Sunlight)[http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-problem-with-vitamin-a/]

    • Contains Methylisothiazolinone, a skin allergen

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

  • Cetaphil Redness Relieving Daily Facial Moisturizer, SPF 20*

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Good UVA protection

    • Excellent UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Clinique Mineral Sunscreen Fluid For Face, SPF 50*

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • COOLA Suncare Sport Mineral Sunscreen Stick, SPF 50*

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Cover FX Clear Cover Invisible Sunscreen, SPF 30*

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • CyberDERM Simply Zinc Sun Whip, SPF 30

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • Drunk Elephant Umbra, Sheer Defense, SPF 30

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Eau Thermale Avene Ultra-Light Hydrating Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 50+

    • Score: 3/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Goddess Garden Organics Everyday Natural Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 50

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • Kiehl's Super Fluid UV Mineral Defense Sunscreen, SPF 50+

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Good UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Kiss My Face Organics Face & Body Sunscreen, SPF 30

    • Score: 1/10 (Good)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • La Roche-Posay Face Anthelios 50 Mineral Ultra Light Sunscreen Fluid, SPF 50

    • Score: 3/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

  • Neutrogena Age Shield Anti-Oxidant Face Lotion Sunscreen, SPF 70

    • Score: 7/10 (Poor)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Contains oxybenzone, a hormone disrupting chemical ((read for more info on oxybenzone + other chemical sunscreen ingredients))[http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-trouble-with-sunscreen-chemicals/]

    • Contains Methylisothiazolinone, a skin allergen

    • High health concern

  • Neutrogena Pure & Free Liquid Sunscreen, SPF 50

    • Score: 6/10 (Poor)

    • SPF may be less than advertised

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Neutrogena Sensitive Skin Sunscreen, SPF 60+

    • Score: 10/10 (Worst)

    • SPF value may be less than advertised

    • Contains retinyl palmitate, which may damage sun-exposed skin (READ about the risk of VITAMIN A + Sunlight)[http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-problem-with-vitamin-a/]

    • (Ironically) Contains Methylisothiazolinone, a skin allergen

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concerns

  • Neutrogena Sheer Zinc Dry-Touch Sunscreen, SPF 50

    • Score: 1/10 (Excellent)

    • Excellent UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Low health concern

  • Neutrogena Ultra Sheer Dry-Touch Sunscreen, SPF 30

    • Score: 5/10 (Okay)

    • Contains oxybenzone, a hormone disrupting chemical ((read for more info on oxybenzone + other chemical sunscreen ingredients))[http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-trouble-with-sunscreen-chemicals/]

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • High health concern

  • Supergoop! Super Power Sunscreen Mousse, SPF 50

    • Score: 3/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Vanicream Sunscreen Sport Lotion, SPF 35

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Good UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

  • Vichy Laboratoires Ideal Capital Soleil 50 Ultra Light Sunscreen, SPF 50

    • Score: 4/10 (Okay)

    • Moderate UVA protection

    • Moderate UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

    • Contains oxybenzone, a hormone disrupting chemical ((read for more info on oxybenzone + other chemical sunscreen ingredients))[http://www.ewg.org/sunscreen/report/the-trouble-with-sunscreen-chemicals/]

  • Yes to Cucumbers Soothing Natural Sunscreen Stick, SPF 30

    • Score: 2/10 (Good)

    • Good UVA protection

    • Good UVA/UVB balance

    • Moderate health concern

If you don't see your specific sunscreen (not just brand) on here, then feel free to check the website out! FYI, I don't think they look at Asian brands (Biore, Missha, etc.) or expensive ones (Elta MD, Skinceuticals, Peter Thomas Roth, Murad, Obage etc.)

Also, this webite gives a good succinct overview of sunscreen protection and ingredients. According to it, physical sunscreens (those that contain titanium dioxide and/or zinc oxide) are your best bet because they offer broad spectrum UV protection (UVB, UVA1, UVA2) and pose low health risks, whereas some ingredients in chemical sunscreens can

form free radicals and can contribute to skin aging, cause irritation, allergic reactions, and possible long term health effects.

TL;DR Based in the sunscreens in this list, your best bets are

  • Aveeno Baby Continuous Protection Sensitive Skin Lotion Sunscreen, SPF 50 ($11)

  • Cetaphil Redness Relieving Daily Facial Moisturizer, SPF 20 ($15)

  • COOLA Suncare Sport Mineral Sunscreen Stick, SPF 50 ($26)

  • CyberDERM Simply Zinc Sun Whip, SPF 30 ($40)

  • Drunk Elephant Umbra, Sheer Defense, SPF 30 ($26)

  • Goddess Garden Organics Everyday Natural Sunscreen Lotion, SPF 50

  • Neutrogena Sheer Zinc Dry-Touch Sunscreen, SPF 50 ($11)