What are the three main characteristics a critique reaction paper must have?
An article critique is an assignment that requires a student to critically read a research article and reflect upon it. The key task is to identify the strong and weak sides of the piece and assess how well the author interprets its sources. Simply put, a critique reflects upon the validity and effectiveness of the article's author's arguments in his or her work. Show
The key to success in writing this paper is critical thinking. The task of every research article author is to convince readers of the correctness of their viewpoint, even if it is skewed. Thus, the only ways to distinguish solid arguments from weak ones are to be a good researcher, have the right tools to pick out facts from fiction and possess solid critical thinking skills. How to write a critique paper – In this guide, we will take you through the process of writing this type of work step by step. However, before we move on, it is worth noting that the main purpose of a good article critique is to bring up points that determine whether a reviewed article is either correct or incorrect—much like you would do while writing a persuasive essay. Although the purpose is similar, the structure of the article critique that we are going to address in this guide is slightly different from the standard 5-paragraph essay; however, both formats are suitable for convincing readers about the validity of your point of view. How to Critique an Article: The Main StepsThis form of assignment is naturally challenging and rather confusing. It is no wonder why students may begin to feel overwhelmed with figuring out how to write an article critique. To help you get your task done with ease, we have prepared a simple 3-step guide on how to summarize and critique an article: Step 1: Reading the ArticleFirst of all, to critique the article, you need to read it carefully. It is recommended to read the piece several times—until you fully understand the information presented for a better outcome. Next, you need to address the following questions: 1. Why is the article's author considered an expert in their field? What makes a particular author's opinion sound valid? Does the author know about the topic? What do other field experts say about the author? Is the article's author covered in academic praise or not taken seriously? 2. What is the author's thesis/hypothesis? What is the main message the author is trying to convey? Is this message clear? Or are there just plenty of general phrases without any specific details? 3. Who is the article's target audience? Is the article geared toward a general audience? Or does it appeal to a specific group of people and use only understandable language for that audience? 4. Are the arguments presented valid? Are the sources used by the author from all over the place? Does it seem like some sources are taken from areas that share a cult-like vocabulary? 5. What are the logical fallacies in the author's viewpoint? Are there any logical blindspots? How much do they affect the outcome? 6. Is the conclusion clear and logical? Found Yourself in a Situation Where You Type 'write an essay for me'?Professional writing help is right here. Get Started Step 2: Collecting ProofThe first step will help you read and understand the piece, look at it from a critical point of view, and reflect upon it. Now, when you have an idea about which way you should be heading in your critique paper, it is the time to start gathering evidence. Here are the main steps you should undertake: 1. Define Whether the Author Is Following Formal Logic Often, undereducated people have some common logical fallacies. An example is to accept certain information based on the feelings and/or emotions it evokes rather than focusing on the supporting arguments. Here is a list of some common examples of logical fallacies with brief explanations of each:
2. Search for Any Biased Opinions in the Article 3. Pay Attention to the Way the Author Interprets Others’ Texts. Does He or She Look at Others’ Viewpoints through Inappropriate Political Lenses? When reading and re-reading the article, find and highlight cases in which the author overstates the importance of some things due to his or her own beliefs. Then, to polish your mental research instruments, go back to point 1 of this list to review the list of logical fallacies you can look out for. 4. Check Cited Sources For example, let's look at Breitbart news. How would you define whether it is an untrustworthy source or not? To rate trustworthiness, one should know about its long history of distorting facts to suit a far-right agenda. Learning this requires paying a lot of attention to local and international news. 5. Evaluate the Language Used in the Article Just to give you a clear example of what you should be looking for: some words have cultural meanings attached to them, which can create a confrontation in the article. Such terms can place people, objects, or ideas into the 'them' side in the 'us vs. them' scenario. For example, if someone conservative refers to an opponent using the word “leftist”, this can be considered a form of attacking the messenger and not the message. A similar concept applies to a case when someone progressive refers to an opponent using the word “bigot”. Using such language in an article is a clear sign of logical fallacies. Authors use it to discredit their opponents on the merit of who they are rather than what they say. This is poor word choice because the debate does not get resolved. 6. Question the Research Methods in Scientific Articles This may not always be mandatory, but if you write an article critique for a scientific piece, you are expected to question and evaluate how the author did their research. To do this, ask the following questions:
Step 3: Formatting Your PaperJust like any other written assignment, a critique paper should be formatted and structured properly. A standard article critique consists of four parts: an introduction, summary, analysis, and conclusion. Below is a clear checklist to help you grasp the idea of how a good paper should be formatted: Introduction
Summary
Critique
Conclusion
How to Critique a Journal ArticleSo, you were assigned to write a critique paper for a journal article? If you are not sure where to start, here is a step-by-step guide on how to critique a journal article: 1. Collect basic information
2. Read the article once and re-read after 3.Write your critique based on the evidence you have collected
You might also be interested in an article about how to write a descriptive essay. How to Critique a Research ArticleIf you are wondering how to critique a research article in particular, below we’ve outlined the key steps to follow. Before you start writing:
While reading:
Struggling to find the strong and weak points that can shape your critique? Here is a simple checklist to help you understand what to critique in a research article (separated by sections): Introduction1. Problem
2. Review of the Relevant Literature
3. Hypothesis
Method1. Participants
2. Instruments
3. Design and Procedures
Results
Discussion, Conclusion, or Suggestions
Abstract or Summary
Overall Impression
As you go through all these steps, you can transition to writing. When writing your critique paper, you should critically evaluate the research article you have read and use the evidence collected from the piece. To help you structure your research article critique properly, here is a sample outline of a critique of research for the article The Effects of Early Education on Children's Competence in Elementary School: 1. Bibliographic Information
2. Summary of the Article
3. Critique
4. Conclusion
You can always ask our professional essay writers for help. Leave us a notice write a research paper for me and we'll do it for you asap! Video Guide: How to Write an Article CritiqueArticle Critique ExampleNow, as you know how to write this type of assignment step by step, our nursing essay writing service are going to share an example of journal article critique to help you grasp the idea of how the finished work should look. A review of the article: Exploring Equity in Ontario. A Provincial Scan of Equity Policies across School Boards A review of the article: Exploring Equity in Ontario. A Provincial Scan of Equity Policies across School Boards This browser does not support PDFs. Please download the PDF to view it: Download PDF “The education system cannot address what it does not acknowledge” Need help with your paper? You can buy essay at our professional writing service. Still Struggling to Grasp the Concept?Writing an article critique is not easy because it requires lots of time to do background research. Not everyone has the time and energy to put into learning volumes about the many sides of an issue. Here you can find argumentative essay writer for any topic you can think of. Contact them today to get a high-quality article critique quickly. Find Your Writer Table of Contents Latest Customer Reviews Customer ID: #405547 Research Paper Had to ask for a revision and I got a revision back in a timely manner as well with no issues. Great work. Writer: Paul Wp. 08/20/2021 Hire WriterLatest Customer Reviews Customer ID: #405434 Research Paper She followed all the instructions, and she even finished 5 days before the due date. She is amazing! Writer: Emma N. 08/01/2021 Hire WriterLatest Customer Reviews Customer ID: #405434 Essay (Any Type) Awesome nursing subject help in such a short amount of time. Expert did the job correctly. I will for sure use her again... What are the 3 parts of a critique paper?Parts of a Critique Essay
Summary. Critique. Conclusion.
What are the characteristics of a critique and reaction paper?A good critique/reaction paper is one that is accurate in presenting the summary and other factual details concerning the subject or work. It's also evaluative, as it presents the writer's overall judgment of the work and explains why this is so by evaluating selected analytical components of the work.
What are the characteristic of a critique?3 characteristics of a good critique are precision, provides, helpful feedback, and being recommended.
What are the characteristics of a good reaction paper?The paper should include a summary of the work, but the main focus is your thoughts, feelings and rationalizations about what's discussed in the original text. This requires analysis of the given work on your part, followed by a focused, well-thought-out reaction backed by outside sources, where applicable.
|